Transcript
You know, usually when we look at a championship game or a, a major election, we just focus entirely on the final score. Right, because the event is officially over. Exactly. The final buzzer sounds, the votes are tallied, and everybody goes home. But there is this incredibly specific, almost, I mean, completely hypocritical behavioral sequence that happens immediately afterward.
Yes. The winners start taunting the losers. Right. And the losers, understandably, they fiercely resent it. I mean, they call the behavior classless, they nurse that psychological injury for months, and they talk endlessly about how terrible and arrogant the winners are acting Until they win the next time Exactly.
Without fail, when those exact same losers win the next contest, they immediately turn around and taunt in turn. They become the exact thing they despised. It's, it's really one of the most reliable behavioral loops in human society. Which is exactly why you are joining us for today's deep dive. Our mission today is to unpack this incredibly common but, uh, really rarely analyzed human behavior, why we taunt, and why we completely forget how much it hurt to be mocked the second we get the upper hand.
Right. And to figure this out, we're gonna be pulling from an essay called The Psychology of Taunting by RJ Starr. Yeah. Starr is a professor of psychology and philosophy, and this essay is part of a broader theoretical framework he developed, uh, which is known as psychological architecture. And to actually understand that amnesia, you know, why the victim immediately becomes the perpetrator, we have to start by looking at the fundamental architecture of why we divide ourselves into groups in the first place.
Right. Before we get to the taunt, we need the precondition. Exactly. Mm-hmm. The deep-seated us versus them mentality. So RJ Starr begins by looking at an evolutionary interpretation of group sorting. And, uh, I wanna emphasize that we should strictly frame this as an interpretation of available evidence, not as a settled absolute historical fact.
Sure, 'cause we can't exactly go back to the Pleistocene Era and check. Right. Exactly. But on this evolutionary account, early human survival in harsh environments depended entirely on forming small cooperative coalitions. Being excluded from your group back then was essentially a death sentence. So our brains evolved to, like, quickly identify who is an ally and to be deeply suspicious of outsiders, just as a matter of basic physical survival.
Yes, exactly. But what really strikes me here is how we apply that ancient life or death programming to things that just, well, that don't matter at all today. Yeah. The threshold for triggering that ancient sorting mechanism is shockingly low today. Starr points to Henri Tajfel's famous minimal group experiments, these were from the 1970s, to illustrate this.
Right. I've heard of these. They're wild. They really are. So Tajfel brought people into a laboratory and divided them into groups based on incredibly trivial things. In one instance, he showed participants paintings by Paul Klee and Wassily Kandinsky, asked which they preferred, and sorted them accordingly.
Based on abstract paintings. Yes. And some participants were even divided completely at random, literally by a coin flip. So these people had never met their group members, they had absolutely nothing to gain from them, and the groups had zero history. Right. Yet when Tajfel asked them to allocate small financial rewards, the participants overwhelmingly favored their own arbitrary group They prioritized complete strangers who just happened to, you know, like the same abstract painting or got the same coin flip.
That alone is bizarre, but the way they distributed those rewards was even stranger, wasn't it? Oh, the core finding was deeply unsettling. The participants didn't just favor their own group. They consistently prioritized a relative gap in rewards over absolute gains for their own side. Wait, a relative gap?
Yeah. Meaning if they had the choice between giving their own group $10 and the other group $10 or giving their own group $5 and the other group just $1, they would choose the latter. Oh, wow. Yes. They would literally take less overall just to ensure they had more than the out-group. Relative standing mattered significantly more to them than actual material gain.
I'm just trying to wrap my head around that. It's like-- Well, it's like running an outdated, incredibly aggressive software program. Our brains are applying high-stakes survival coding to completely low-stakes modern situations like rooting for a baseball team or picking a favorite painter. We'd rather sabotage our own wealth just to make sure someone else is poor.
Which brings us directly to a core concept in psychological architecture, and it's known as Contrastive Identity. Contrastive identity, right. Yeah. So when you join a group, the standing of that group becomes fused with your own self-concept, and because that identity is organized contrastively, it defines itself entirely by what it is not.
Okay, so it needs a contrast. Exactly. If your identity relies on being superior to a rival, it actually requires an out-group to feel secure. It needs that outline, that contrast to exist at all. So if our brains naturally prefer a gap between us and them, and we literally need an out-group to feel secure in our own standing, then the taunt isn't just bad sportsmanship, it's, uh, it's the shovel we use to actively dig that trench.
That's a great way to put it. The taunt is performing highly specific psychological work, and RJ Starr breaks this down into four distinct functions. Let's get into those. What's the first one? The first function is what he calls converting a borrowed victory. He cites the work of psychologist Robert Cialdini, who documented a phenomenon known as basking in reflected glory.
Basking in reflected glory. Right. Cialdini found that university students were far more likely to wear clothing with school colors on a Monday morning if their football team had won over the weekend. Furthermore, they would use the pronoun we to describe the victory, you know, saying, "We won." Right. I mean, think about the last time you yelled, "We won," at your television.
Did you feel your own pulse race as if you had been on the field, even though you were, like, sitting on the couch eating nachos, not throwing the football? You didn't play in the game. The victory belongs entirely to the athletes. Exactly. So the taunt serves as this, this psychological alchemy that converts a collective achievement, one the supporter had absolutely no physical part in, into personal status.
I see. Yeah. By looking at a rival fan in the office on Monday morning and mocking them, the fan is personally claiming a piece of that victory. The taunt transfers the win from the stadium to the individual. So a taunt is essentially cashing a check someone else wrote. You just quietly pocket the emotional winnings.
But, uh, just feeling superior silently at your desk doesn't seem to satisfy people. They always need to rub it in. And that requirement introduces Starr's second function, which is the absolute requirement of a witness. A victory on its own is just a sterile event on a scoreboard. It doesn't actually mean anything relationally until the other side actually registers it.
Right. So the taunt is deliberately designed to extract visible, undeniable distress from the loser. The taunter is looking for anger or silence or embarrassment. 'Cause that proves they won. Yes. That visible reaction is what confirms the new relation of superiority in real time. Total indifference completely starves the taunt of its function.
Which explains why people get so much louder and, you know, more obnoxious if the person they are taunting just tries to ignore them. The taunter needs that reaction to validate their new status. If the loser doesn't care, the taunter hasn't really won anything. Precisely. But it's not just about the loser, is it?
Because there are usually other people watching. Right, and the third function looks at the audience standing directly behind the target. The loser is the object of the taunt, sure, but the taunt is frequently delivered in front of the taunter's own group. As a kind of performance. Yes. In that specific context, the taunt acts as a loyalty display.
It proves your unshakable commitment to your own side by showing you are willing to publicly express that attachment at a rival's expense, and your in-group actively rewards this display with approval and belonging. Man And then we get to the fourth function, which honestly might be the most primal and frankly, slightly terrifying one because it happens completely beneath our conscious control.
The reward of rival failure. Starr points to a fascinating neuroimaging study by Mina Cikara and her colleagues, and this involved diehard Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees fans. Classic rivalry. Exactly. So they put these fans into fMRI machines and monitored their brain activity while they watched simulated baseball plays.
The researchers found that whenever a rival team failed, even if that rival was playing against the completely neutral third team, like the Baltimore Orioles, the neural reward centers in the fans' brains lit up with a dopamine response. That is wild. Our brains literally give us a chemical reward for watching our rivals fail, even if their failure doesn't benefit our team in the standings at all.
The data goes even further than that, actually. The strength of that specific neural reward response in the fMRI machine actually predicted how likely those individual fans said they were to heckle, insult, or even physically threaten a rival fan later on. Wow. Okay. So synthesizing these four functions, we see how a taunt operates.
It takes a borrowed victory, confirms it by extracting distress from a witness, signals tribal loyalty to the in-group, and delivers a literal neurochemical reward. That's the exact mechanism. Okay, let's zoom out here for a second because this all makes perfect sense in the context of a baseball game or a football stadium, but this behavior doesn't just stay on the field, does it?
No. The mechanism easily spills over into spaces it was never meant for. RJ Starr outlines how this contest template travels across society. Now, the clearest contemporary template for this behavioral grammar is sports. You have agreed upon rules, a neutral referee, a declared winner, a highly public result, and a scheduled rematch.
Right. But we must clarify here that sports is simply the most legible template we have today. It is absolutely not the historical origin of taunting. Oh, for sure. Taunting has existed throughout human history in tribal warfare, interpersonal disputes, and rigid social hierarchies long before organized sports were ever codified.
But because the sports template is so recognizable and, you know, ingrained in us from childhood, we just basically copy and paste that exact logic onto other, far more consequential parts of society, and the most obvious one being elections. The migration to partisan political identity is really seamless because democratic elections share the formal structural skeleton of a contest.
You have a set date, a declared winner, and a scheduled rematch in two or four years. Right. The mechanics are almost identical. And this dynamic applies identically to both major political parties. Both sides alternate control over time, and both sides' taunts following a victory are structurally indistinguishable from one another.
Yeah. The rhetoric of the winning party gloating over the losing party maps perfectly onto a championship celebration, but there is a massive boundary difference that makes this migration destructive. Exactly. Because when an election ends, the winner assumes legal authority to govern the loser. The outcome actually distributes real power and authority over the daily lives, taxes, and rights of the people who voted the other way.
Right. Because when a football game ends, the fans just go home. The winner doesn't get to dictate what the loser eats for breakfast the next day. Today, we are seeing incredibly high levels of what political scientists call affective polarization. This is where political party affiliation shifts from being just a set of policy preferences to a totalizing lifestyle identity.
And because the identity is so all-encompassing, an electoral defeat lands not just as a policy setback, but as a physical threat, you know, a defeat of the self. Yes. But isn't applying sports logic to an election inherently dangerous? I mean, you can take off a jersey at the end of the day, but you cannot opt out of a shared political community.
You still have to live next door to the people you are taunting. Applying that template creates deep systemic strain. The stakes are profoundly real, but the psychological processing remains completely symbolic, and the template migrates even further out. Where else does it go? It travels into rivalries between nations, where individual citizens stand in for entire states.
A citizen will claim personal credit for their government's geopolitical or economic achievements and aim their taunts at individuals in another country who had absolutely no control over their own government's failures. It also travels into religion, which Starr points out is infinitely more complicated because there's no agreed-upon referee to blow the whistle.
Religious rivalries utilize the contest frame to argue for ultimate cosmic meaning. Because there is no visible scoreboard and no neutral earthly referee to declare whose truth claims are objectively correct, no historical outcome ever permanently settles the matter for both sides. So they just keep going.
That is why conflicts of this nature drag out across centuries. Military victories, demographic shifts, or cultural dominance are interpreted by the winning side as divine vindication, and the taunting follows as a way to prove that their ultimate truth prevailed. But then Starr takes this framework into divisions like race and sexual orientation, and this feels like a completely different landscape.
You can't compare a racial hierarchy to a baseball game. No, you can't, and Starr is very careful to distinguish this landscape. Unlike sports, elections, or even national rivalries, race and sexual orientation are absolutely not contests. Right. No one chose the category they were born into, there is no scheduled event to win, and there is no scheduled rematch.
Applying the contest template to these specific divisions means a person has to actively invent a contest that does not exist. And there's a huge asymmetry there. Furthermore, yes, there is a severe asymmetry of power here due to long histories of systemic dominance. Because of that historical weight, a taunt directed downward in these categories functions purely as an enforcement of rank.
It is not a celebration of a win. It is a mechanism for maintaining a brutal hierarchy. Which brings us back to the central puzzle we started with. If taunting in all these different arenas, from the stadium to the ballot box to societal hierarchies, if it's so incredibly destructive, and the people receiving the taunts feel that pain so acutely, why do they do it?
Why do the victims of this behavior instantly become perpetrators the moment they win? This brings us to the theoretical core of the essay. RJ Starr introduces a construct he proposes within psychological architecture called positional learning. Positional learning. Okay. Okay. Now, it is vital to state explicitly that positional learning is a theoretical proposition proposed by Starr to explain this behavioral loop.
It is an inferred psychological mechanism, not a tested empirical finding in a laboratory. Wait, I'm struggling with this. Because, like, if I get mocked after a loss, I know the person mocking me is acting like a jerk. It hurts, and I hate them for it. How could my brain possibly misfile that experience so badly that I turn around and do the exact same thing to them later?
That feels like a massive glitch in human cognition. It does look like a glitch until you examine how the brain processes simultaneous inputs. Think about the exact moment a person is taunted after a painful loss. Two profound emotional injuries are happening at the precise same millisecond. Okay, the pain of losing.
The deep pain of losing the contest, yes. Yeah. And the sharp pain of being publicly mocked by the winner. Because they arrive at the exact same time, the brain conflates them. It attributes the pain entirely to the position of being a loser rather than to the practice of taunting. Ah. So because the winners aren't suffering, and I am, my brain just assumes the pain is a baked-in feature of the losing position.
Exactly. The injury is processed and stored as a debt to be repaid rather than a moral principle to be upheld. The lesson you internalize in that moment of humiliation is losing is agonizing, not taunting is cruel. It's like, it's like getting burned by a hot stove, and instead of learning the universal lesson that stoves are dangerous and we should turn them off, you just learn that you need to be the one pushing your opponent onto the burners the next time you're in the kitchen.
That captures the mechanism of positional learning perfectly. And Starr explicitly differentiates this theory from existing psychological models. How so? For instance, it is not simply observational learning, which is where you learn a new behavior by watching someone else do it, because people, even children, already know how to taunt.
They don't need a tutorial. Right. And you mentioned earlier it's not identification with the aggressor either. Identification with the aggressor is a well-known defense mechanism where a victim unconsciously takes on the traits of someone threatening them in order to master their own anxiety. But in the context of a sports rivalry or political election, the taunted person doesn't identify with the rival at all.
They still fundamentally despise them. Okay, so what about just like basic retaliation, hitting back? Positional learning is distinct from basic retaliation or the norm of reciprocity because those existing concepts completely fail to explain the failure to classify. Let's unpack that. What exactly is the failure to classify?
When you retaliate against someone, you usually recognize that you are inflicting the exact same harm that was done to you. You know you are hitting them back. Positional learning explains why people completely fail to classify their own taunting as the exact same cruelty they just suffered. Because they learned a lesson of the position, not the practice.
Exactly. Because the lesson was filed under position rather than practice, the person genuinely does not generalize the concept of cruelty to their own conduct when the positions finally reverse. They just see themselves as cashing in a debt they are rightfully owed. But surely some people know what they are doing is cruel, right?
Like, they recognize it, and they just do it anyway. Starr clarifies that boundary. If a person knows taunting is cruel and they clearly remember how much it hurt when it happened to them, but they consciously decide to do it anyway because they feel the other side deserves it, that is a deliberate moral exception.
Oh, I see. That operates through cognitive justification. Positional learning, on the other hand, is specifically about the failure of generalization, where the cognitive recognition of cruelty never actually reaches your own conduct at all. And because outcomes alternate in things like elections and sports leagues, this just creates a perpetual motion machine of resentment.
Starr calls this mechanism grievance rotation. Because the outcomes alternate back and forth, each side only clearly remembers their own most recent injury. Right. When the election results come in, the losers remember the mockery they are receiving perfectly, but they remember their own previous mockery from four years ago vaguely or not at all.
So every aggressive move feels completely justified by the previous move. It creates an endless spinning cycle sustained by literally everyone who has ever lost. Is there any way to break that cycle? Does the lesson ever successfully transfer from the position you're in to the conduct you choose? Starr outlines four specific theoretical conditions where the lesson does successfully transfer, which interrupts the cycle.
First, if the psychological injury is remembered as a deeply personal individual experience rather than a generalized abstract group grievance. Okay. And the second. Second, if the person's identity is less reliant on that contrastive organization we discussed earlier. Meaning they don't fundamentally need the other group to fail in order to feel good about themselves in the morning.
They have their own internal foundation. Exactly. Third, if the person has the cognitive capacity to regulate their neural reward response, that rush of dopamine when they see the rival fail, long enough to consult their memory of how much losing actually hurt. They have to pause the chemical hit. That's tough.
It is. And fourth, if the person's in-group actively models and rewards graciousness rather than mockery. If those four specific conditions are met, the person can intercept the behavior and interrupt the cycle. So what does this all mean when we pull back? We've talked about evolutionary origins, minimal groups, brain chemistry, and theoretical models.
What is the broader proposition of R.J. Starr's essay? The broader psychological proposition here challenges a very common assumption we have about life, that experience alone produces psychological maturity. We often believe that just going through hard things like losing or being humiliated naturally makes us wiser and more empathetic.
Right. But Starr argues that experience is always filtered through our identity structures, and those specific structures actively resist the perspective-taking that true maturity requires. The taunted person has all the raw data they need to recognize the taunt is cruel, but their contrastive identity files it away under position, and the profound lesson is completely lost.
So to actually achieve maturity, we can't just rely on having experiences. We have to actively examine the structure of our own identities. Starr connects this to a terminal concept he calls Psychological Adulthood. This is the incredibly rare capacity to hold a group membership without needing a degraded, defeated other to define it.
That sounds amazing. It is a psychological state where your chosen group provides you with a warm sense of belonging but not a hierarchical sense of rank. In psychological adulthood, you can win a contest without needing the loser to suffer to validate it, and you can lose a contest without banking the injury as a debt to be weaponized later.
That sounds incredibly difficult to achieve, especially in our current cultural climate, but it also sounds absolutely necessary. I want to read the final line of RJ Starr's essay verbatim because it really captures the entire architecture we've been unpacking today. He writes, "A taunt is what an identity sounds like when it cannot yet stand without someone beneath it."
It perfectly distills the structural vulnerability that drives the entire cycle. It really does. So for you listening, as you navigate the world this week, think about how social media algorithms are built today. If our brains are literally hardwired to receive chemical dopamine rewards from watching our rivals fail, are, are digital platforms just massive automated taunting engines designed to harvest that exact neurochemical response for engagement?
Just something to mull over. This has been a deep dive into RJ Starr's Psychological Architecture. Thanks for joining us.