Advanced Studies in Psychology

Graduate-level inquiry into psychology as a discipline

About this series

This series is written for advanced undergraduate and graduate students of psychology. It engages the field as a discipline, examining foundational assumptions, theoretical frameworks, research methods, and the limits of psychological explanation. The work prioritizes conceptual rigor and disciplinary context over summary or persuasion.

Orientation for Advanced Readers
Foundations RJ Starr Foundations RJ Starr

The Cognitive Revolution Revisited: What Exactly Was Revolutionary?

This piece reexamines the cognitive revolution in psychology, arguing that it reorganized rather than overturned the discipline’s foundational commitments. It analyzes how cognitive models preserved explanatory priorities inherited from behaviorism, reintroduced internal processes under computational constraints, and expanded psychology’s reach without resolving deeper questions about meaning, subjectivity, and interpretation.

Read More
Foundations RJ Starr Foundations RJ Starr

Freud, Not as Clinician, but as Theorist of Meaning

This piece repositions Freud as a theorist of psychological meaning rather than a clinician, examining his account of symptoms, conflict, and symbolic coherence. It argues that Freud’s enduring contribution lies in his interpretive model of mind, which challenges psychology’s preference for mechanistic explanation and continues to illuminate how experience is organized through narrative and conflict.

Read More
Foundations RJ Starr Foundations RJ Starr

Behaviorism as a Moral Project, Not Just a Methodological One

This piece reframes behaviorism as more than a methodological corrective, arguing that it functioned as a moral project shaped by cultural ideals of control, efficiency, and predictability. It examines how behaviorist assumptions continue to influence psychological theory, research norms, and applied interventions long after behaviorism’s theoretical dominance declined.

Read More
Foundations RJ Starr Foundations RJ Starr

The Invention of the Normal Mind

This piece examines how psychology came to construct the idea of a normal mind through statistical practices, standardized measurement, and population-level reasoning. It traces how normality acquired normative force, shaping diagnosis, research priorities, and institutional judgments, while obscuring the historical and methodological choices embedded in what now appears psychologically self-evident.

Read More
Foundations RJ Starr Foundations RJ Starr

From Soul to System: What Was Lost When Psychology Became a Science

This piece analyzes psychology’s historical shift from philosophical and moral inquiry toward system-level scientific explanation. It examines how the discipline’s pursuit of methodological legitimacy reshaped its language, priorities, and epistemic boundaries, and considers what was displaced when psychological phenomena were reframed as mechanisms rather than sites of meaning and human significance.

Read More
Foundations RJ Starr Foundations RJ Starr

Psychology’s Original Split: Explanation Versus Understanding

This piece examines psychology’s foundational epistemological tension between explanation and understanding, tracing its origins in nineteenth-century human science debates and its institutionalization within the discipline. It analyzes how this unresolved divide continues to shape theory, method, evidentiary standards, and the treatment of meaning, causality, and case material in contemporary psychological inquiry.

Read More
RJ Starr RJ Starr

Orientation for Advanced Readers

This essay offers an orientation to a body of psychological writing developed over decades and transferred to this platform as an active archive. It clarifies how the work is meant to be read, not as instruction or argument, but as sustained disciplinary inquiry. The focus is on posture, ambiguity, and the creative vitality of remaining intellectually oriented within psychology over time.

Read More